Show simple item record

dc.contributor.authorHofmann, Bjørn
dc.date.accessioned2019-11-20T08:10:44Z
dc.date.available2019-11-20T08:10:44Z
dc.date.created2013-09-02T13:21:49Z
dc.date.issued2013
dc.identifier.citationGMS Health Technology Assessment. 2013, 9 .
dc.identifier.issn1861-8863
dc.identifier.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/11250/2629390
dc.description.abstractThe founding disciplines of HTA are clearly scientific, and have been firmly based among the natural sciences. However, common definitions of HTA indicate that HTA is something more than the “pure application of science”. This article investigates whether this “something” also makes HTA an art. The question of whether HTA is a science or an art is pursued in two specific and historically rich directions. The first is whether HTA is an art in the same way that medicine is described as an art. It has been argued extensively that medicine is based on two different and partly incompatible cultures, i.e., the natural sciences and humanities. Medicine is based on disciplines within the natural sciences, while its value judgments have been placed in the humanities camp. This dichotomy is present in HTA as well, and the first part of the investigation illustrates how HTA is an art in terms of its inherent and constitutive value-judgments. The second part of the science/art-scrutiny leads us to the ancient (Hippocratic) concept of art, téchne, where we find an etymological and a conceptual link between HTA and art. It demonstrates HTA is not an arbitrary process, even though it involves value judgments and relates complex decision making processes. As an art (téchne) HTA has a specific subject matter, requires inquiry and mastery of general rational principles, and is oriented to a specific end. In conclusion, the science-or-art-question makes sense in two specific perspectives, illustrating that HTA is a science based art. This has implications for the practice of HTA, for its education, and for the status of its results.
dc.description.abstractHealth Technology Assessment – science or art?
dc.language.isoeng
dc.titleHealth Technology Assessment – science or art?
dc.typePeer reviewed
dc.typeJournal article
dc.description.versionpublishedVersion
dc.source.pagenumber8
dc.source.volume9
dc.source.journalGMS Health Technology Assessment
dc.identifier.doi10.3205/hta000114
dc.identifier.cristin1046246
cristin.unitcode7502,0,0,0
cristin.unitnameFolkehelseinstituttet
cristin.ispublishedtrue
cristin.fulltextoriginal
cristin.qualitycode1


Files in this item

Thumbnail

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record